Ornithological Applications · 1965 · 26 citations · 2 references
Life SciencesEcologyZoologyOrnithologyPopulation EcologyBird ConservationBird Population BiologyEgg BiologyEgg DistributionEgg FertilityEgg QualityEgg Distribution EfficiencyEgg Distribution NetworksEgg Distribution PatternEgg Mass DistributionEgg Morphometrics
The Brown-headed Cowbird (Molothrus ater) often places just one egg in the nest of a host but sometimes deposits two, three, or even more.Since about 60 per cent of parasitized nests contain but a single cowbird egg each (Friedmann, 1963: 12)) one might suppose that the cowbird tends to use a nest but once and does otherwise only under special circumstances, as when a different nest is not available or when two or more cowbirds cross paths unwittingly.On the other hand, a field observer, finding several cowbird eggs in a nest, might suppose that cowbirds find some nests particularly attractive and return to lay in them repeatedly.Which of these two opposing suppositions is true?Or is neither of them true?Intuitively, one would think that an intelligent creature, such as a bird, would exercise some choice-seeking out different nests for each egg if possible or returning repeatedly to a preferred nest if possible.Obviously one course will tend to increase the ratio of nests with one cowbird egg, and the other course will tend to increase the ratio of nests with more than one cowbird egg.Any exercise of choice whatsoever, or any instinctive tendency to seek out or avoid certain nests, will cause the proportion of nests with one egg, two eggs, three eggs, and so on to be different from that predicted by chance alone.If a given number of cowbird eggs are laid at random among a given number of nests, the pattern of distribution to be expected can be calculated easily.The probability that a nest will get 0, 1, 2, 3, . . .cowbird eggs is given by each successive term in the Poisson series, as follows: c2e-C c3e-c e-c, ce-c, -, -, . . ., where c = number of cowbird eggs 2! 3! number of nests in sample ' that is, the cowbird eggs per nest in the sample, the average expectation, or the sample mean; and e = 2.71828 . . ., the base of natural logarithms.The number e-c for any value of c can be read directly from a table of exponentials.The sum of all the numbers in the series is 1, because the sum of all the probabilities is certainty.To express each probability, not just as a fraction, but as the number of nests in a category, each member of the series may be multiplied by N, the number of nests in the sample, thus: c2Ne-c c3Ne-c Ne-C, cNe-c, -2! ' 3! ' ."It was Preston (1948) who first considered the distribution of cowbird eggs in this light.He examined five reports on host nests and found that the distribution of cowbird eggs in each sample was not as close to that predicted by chance as when he analyzed just the parasitized segment of the sample and considered the distribution of subsequent cowbird eggs after the first in each nest.Here the observed pattern was remarkably close to the predicted pattern in all five studies.He concluded (p.115) "the first cowbird egg in a nest is not placed at random, but all subsequent ones are."For his analysis he used data from the following studies: Friedmann (1929:248) on the Louisiana Waterthrush (Se&us motacilla) in several Eastern localities;
2
The Cowbird (M. Ater) and the Cuckoo (C. Canorus)
F. W. Preston · Ecology · 1948 · 15 citations
Life Sciences, Biology, Zoology +13