Contaminant Mixing at Pipe Joints: Comparison between Laboratory Flow Experiments and Computational Fluid Dynamics Models

Abstract

This paper presents computational simulations and experiments of water flow and contaminant transport through pipes with incomplete mixing at pipe joints. The hydraulics and contaminant transport were modeled using computational fluid dynamics software that solves the continuity, momentum, energy, and species equations (laminar and turbulent) using finite-element methods. Simulations were performed of experiments consisting of individual and multiple pipe joints where tracer and clean water were separately introduced into the pipe junction. Results showed that the incoming flow streams generally remained separated within the junction, leading to incomplete mixing of the tracer. Simulations of the mixing matched the experimental results when appropriate scaling of the tracer diffusivity (via the turbulent Schmidt number) was calibrated based on results of single-joint experiments using cross and double-T configurations. Results showed that a turbulent Schmidt number between ∼0.001–0.01 was able to account for enhanced mixing caused by instabilities along the interface of impinging flows. Unequal flow rates within the network were also shown to affect the outlet concentration at each pipe junction, with "enhanced" or "reduced" mixing possible depending on the relative flow rates entering the junction. This paper was presented at the 8th Annual Water Distribution Systems Analysis Symposium which was held with the generous support of Awwa Research Foundation (AwwaRF).