Stability and Persistence of Fish Faunas and Assemblages in Three Midwestern Streams

Abstract

Long term stability of summer fish assemblages was examined in three distinct systems: Piney Creek, a medium-sized Ozark upland tributary of the White River, Arkansas; Brier Creek, a small prairie-margin stream, tributary to the Red River, Oklahoma; and the Kiamichi River, a medium-sized river in the Ouachita Uplands draining into the Red River, Oklahoma. Sampling periods and numbers of surveys of the three stream systems were 14 yr and six collections for Piney Creek, 17 yr and five surveys for Brier Creek, and 5 yr and three surveys for the Kiamichi River. The fish faunas of all three streams were persistent (regarding presence-absence of species). In all three streams overall faunal structure was stable, as indicated by similarity indices and by concordance of rank abundance of the common species in each stream across all collection years. The results corroborated a conclusion from earlier work that the total fish fauna is more stable in a more environmentally benign stream (Piney Creek) than in a stream subject to greater environmental extremes (Brier Creek). The fish fauna of the Kiamichi River was also stable across three survey periods with respect to rank order of species abundance. Stability of the fish assemblages at individual locations on all three streams was variable, but four of five locations on Brier Creek, and all five locations on Piney Creek exhibited significant concordance overall in ranks of species abundance. Of 59 possible cases, assemblages at 27 individual locations (=46%) on the three streams showed assemblage stability >0.60 between survey periods. We conclude that at the level of whole-stream faunas, all three of these midwestern streams were stable across the survey years, and that many, but not all, individual locations had relatively stable fish assemblages.