Problems In Evaluating Community Development

Donald E. Voth

Community Development Society Journal · 1975 · 21 citations · 5 references

Concepts

Abstract

Community development for this paper refers to the “locality development” model of S. T. Bruyn [2], and evaluation research follows closely the presentation by Suchman [16] and -Campbell and Stanley’s treatment of quasi-experimental design [3].Five major problems in the evaluation of community development are identified and discussed. They are (1) ambiguity of objectives in community development; (2) the lack of a clearly articulated causal model of the community development process; (3) inability to control assignment to experimental and control groups or communities; (4) a combination of weak effects, crude measurement, and small samples; and (5) political problems in community development goal statements, administration of evaluation, and utilization of evaluation results.Solutions are suggested for several of these problems. The use of dynamic causal models and more extensive use of systematically collected secondary data are advocated.

References

5