Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement · 2012 · 48 citations · 14 references
HumanitiesBiologyPhilosophyEvolutionary TheoryMacroevolutionPhilosophy Of BiologyBiological EssentialismEssentialismEvolutionAristotelian BiologyAristotelian EssentialismBiological TheoryHistory Of Scientific TheoriesMetaphysical Essentialism
It is usually maintained by biologists and philosophers alike that essentialism is incompatible with evolutionary biology, and that abandoning essentialism was a precondition of progress being made in the biological sciences. These claims pose a problem for anyone familiar with both evolutionary biology and current metaphysics. Very few current scientific theories enjoy the prestige of evolutionary biology. But essentialism – long in the bad books amongst both biologists and philosophers – has been enjoying a strong resurgence of late amongst analytical philosophers with a taste for metaphysics. Indeed, to impartial observers it is likely to appear that both evolutionary biology and essentialism are as well supported in their respective domains as could reasonably be expected. There is thus at least a prima facie tension here between evolutionary biology, metaphysics (of a reputable sort) and, as we shall see, pre-theoretical common sense.
14
Evolution, Population Thinking, and Essentialism
Elliott Sober · Philosophy of Science · 1980 · 670 citations
Helen Morris Cartwright, David Wiggins · The Philosophical Review · 1982 · 560 citations
Darwinian Metaphysics: Species And The Question Of Essentialism
Samir Okasha · Synthese · 2002 · 337 citations
Categories, life, and thinking
Michael T. Ghiselin · Behavioral and Brain Sciences · 1981 · 279 citations