False Sympathy in Melville's Typee

Mitchell Robert Breitwieser

American Quarterly · 1982 · 32 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

THE ABUNDANCE OF FACTUAL HISTORICAL MATTER AND THE EXPLICIT political concern in Melville's first book, Typee (1846), have led various commentators to view it as a work of social criticism directed against the western cultural, economic, and military colonization of the Marquesan peoples.1 But we cannot accept the didactic content of Typee without reservation: to do so would support the narrator's claim to sympathy for the endangered Marquesans. Such simple trust is untenable: Melville deliberately made his narrator's sympathy eccentric, muddled, and indecisive, and by so doing obliged us to look for the self-interest underlying it. D.H. Lawrence implied that Tommo, the narrator, is so self-involved that he never really sees the Typees, and that he is not really more compatible with them than are the colonialist powers he deplores. However, close attention to Tommo's unreliability does not strip Typee of its polemical political intention. To reach a workable understanding of Melville's thesis, we should combine the view of Typee as social criticism with Lawrence's inquiry into Tommo's preoccupations. A resentful romantic objection to the exercise of social power, Melville contended, was not necessarily true sympathy for the real victims of power, however much it might plead common cause. Such sympathy might be fickle; and it might even be unwittingly complicit in what it resents. Melville's careful development of Tommo's attitudes deepens Tommo's criticism by revealing the affinity between his rebellion and what he rebels against. Tommo and Melville should not be confused: Tommo's stay on