Journal of Experiential Education · 2015 · 17 citations · 17 references
Public HealthBehavioral SciencesPsychologyAdolescent HealthExperimental DesignResearch EthicsClinical Trial EthicsClinical TrialsRandomized Comparative TrialsRandomized Controlled TrialsStudy DesignWilderness SkillsHealth Outcome AssessmentPediatric Trial DesignRandomized Controlled Trial EthicsWilderness TherapyWilderness Trials
There are few high-quality studies using randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in the adventure and wilderness therapy literature. Thus, a unison call is heard for more such studies to be carried out. This article presents a Norwegian wilderness therapy research project that planned to incorporate this “gold standard” that is regarded as the most scientific and rigorous approach available. We did not succeed. Mounting challenges led us to discard the RCT altogether and select other methodologies. Here, we account for the ethical, health outcome, practical, and empirical obstacles that we encountered when attempting to randomize at-risk adolescents into experiment and control groups. Our conclusion is that although RCTs may be superior in some aspects, they hold the potential to become bad science when the interventions are as complex and multi-faceted as adventure and wilderness therapy programs.
17
Manual for the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory
Charles D. Spielberger, Richard L. Gorsuch, Robert E. Lushene · 1970 · 25.4K citations
Multilevel (Hierarchical) Modeling: What It Can and Cannot Do
Andrew Gelman · Technometrics · 2006 · 568 citations · Full text
The Social Construction of What?
John Dupré · The Journal of Philosophy · 2000 · 316 citations