Work and Leisure in the United States and Europe: Why So Different?

Alberto Alesina, Edward L. Glaeser, Bruce Sacerdote

NBER Macroeconomics Annual · 2005 · 295 citations · 49 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Western Europeans work significantly fewer hours than Americans, a pattern that cannot be fully explained by higher tax rates or cultural differences alone. The study aims to show that European labor‑market regulations advocated by unions in declining industries explain most of the U.S.–Europe work hour gap. These regulations, promoted by unions, encourage reduced working hours through policy changes that favor longer vacations and lower work intensity. Americans work about 25 hours per week and 46 weeks per year, whereas Europeans work roughly 18–19 hours per week and 40–46 weeks per year, and the regulatory policies appear to have increased leisure via a social multiplier without boosting employment.

Abstract

Americans average 25.1 working hours per person of working age per week, but the Germans average 18.6 hours. The average American works 46.2 weeks per year, while the French average 40 weeks per year. Why do western Europeans work so much less than Americans? Recent work argues that these differences result from higher European tax rates, but the vast empirical labor-supply literature suggests that tax rates can explain only a small amount of the differences in hours between the United States and Europe. Another popular view is that these differences are explained by long-standing European culture, but Europeans worked more than Americans as late as the 1960s. In this paper, we argue that European labor-market regulations, advocated by unions in declining European industries who argued "work less-work all," explain the bulk of the difference between the United States and Europe. These policies do not seem to have increased employment, but they may have had a more society-wide influence on leisure patterns because of a social multiplier where the returns to leisure increase as more people are taking longer vacations.

References

49