North Carolina Medical Journal · 2015 · 29 citations · 17 references
MedicineEmergency Medical ServicesEmergency MedicineChild WelfareEmergencyInjury SurveillanceChild AbuseChild MaltreatmentChild SafetyIncident ReportingIncident ReportsMandatory ReportingChi-square TestChild Abuse Reporting SystemsChild Maltreatment SurveillanceDescriptive Statistics TablesMaltreatment DisclosureMaltreatment ReportingMandatory Reporting RefusalReporting Barriers
Child maltreatment is underreported in the United States and North Carolina, though mandatory reporting laws require various professionals to report, aiming to reduce this underreporting. The study seeks to determine why emergency medical services professionals in North Carolina may fail to report suspected maltreatment despite mandatory reporting policies. A web-based, anonymous survey of 444 North Carolina EMS professionals was conducted, with descriptive statistics and chi‑square analyses comparing line staff and leadership responses. Results revealed that 38% of respondents were unaware of agency protocols, 25% incorrectly believed the report should be filed by someone else, leadership understood requirements better than line staff, and common reasons for underreporting included belief that others would file (52.3%), uncertainty about witnessing abuse (47.7%), and uncertainty about what to report (41.4%). The survey may not generalize to all North Carolina EMS professionals, and the authors recommend training on proper identification and reporting of child maltreatment and cross‑agency information sharing.
Child maltreatment is underreported in the United States and in North Carolina. In North Carolina and other states, mandatory reporting laws require various professionals to make reports, thereby helping to reduce underreporting of child maltreatment. This study aims to understand why emergency medical services (EMS) professionals may fail to report suspicions of maltreatment despite mandatory reporting policies.A web-based, anonymous, voluntary survey of EMS professionals in North Carolina was used to assess knowledge of their agency's written protocols and potential reasons for underreporting suspicion of maltreatment (n=444). Results were based on descriptive statistics. Responses of line staff and leadership personnel were compared using chi-square analysis.Thirty-eight percent of respondents were unaware of their agency's written protocols regarding reporting of child maltreatment. Additionally, 25% of EMS professionals who knew of their agency's protocol incorrectly believed that the report should be filed by someone other than the person with firsthand knowledge of the suspected maltreatment. Leadership personnel generally understood reporting requirements better than did line staff. Respondents indicated that peers may fail to report maltreatment for several reasons: they believe another authority would file the report, including the hospital (52.3%) or law enforcement (27.7%); they are uncertain whether they had witnessed abuse (47.7%); and they are uncertain about what should be reported (41.4%).This survey may not generalize to all EMS professionals in North Carolina.Training opportunities for EMS professionals that address proper identification and reporting of child maltreatment, as well as cross-agency information sharing, are warranted.
17
Recognising and responding to child maltreatment
Ruth Gilbert, Alison Kemp, June Thoburn et al. · The Lancet · 2008 · 599 citations
Child abuse reporting: teachers’ perceived deterrents
Maureen C. Kenny · Child Abuse & Neglect · 2001 · 296 citations
Terence P. Thornberry, Kimberly L. Henry, Timothy O. Ireland et al. · Journal of Adolescent Health · 2010 · 289 citations · Full text
Social Sciences, Human Development, Adolescent Development +13
Krisann M. Alvarez, Maureen C. Kenny, Brad Donohue et al. · Aggression and Violent Behavior · 2003 · 213 citations