Soviet Studies in History · 1979 · 13 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesHistoryPolitical ScienceHistoriographyPolitical HistoryPolitical InstitutionsMonarchical HistoryRussian HistoryRussian PoliticsRussian SocietySoviet HistorySoviet StudiesEconomic History Of RussiaHistoriography Of RussiaImperial MonarchyNobility In RussiaProvincial LifeSocial History Of RussiaTwentieth-century Historiography
Marshals of the nobility were one of the components of Russia's political structure from the end of the eighteenth to the beginning of the twentieth century. Playing a leading role in the corporative organization of the nobility as an estate, they not only concentrated in their hands the functions of the corporations of the nobility, but also constituted an important link in the administrative-managerial machinery of the Russian monarchy. The broad authority and special status they occupied made them an inseparable component of the life of provincial society virtually from the moment this position was instituted until its abolition in 1917. This was reflected in the most diverse kinds of literature: creative, journalistic, and scholarly. On the whole, prerevolutionary historiography had already produced a general evaluation of the institution of marshals of the nobility. For the period of its history prior to the reforms of the 1860s, this evaluation rested upon a number of studies that retain a certain scholarly value to this day, despite the familiar shortcomings characteristic of historical scholarship with a bias toward the nobility and bourgeoisie. (1) The history of the institution of marshals of the nobility subsequent to the reforms was dealt with only in its most general features in courses for lawyers in public law and in certain public-affairs writings devoted primarily to questions of local administration. (2) However, authors of all points of view were unanimous on one thing: the marshals of the nobility did not lose their significance even after the changes of the 1860s and 1870s. Representatives of the right wing of nobility-oriented historical scholarship saw them as providing a guarantee of the preservation of the dominant position of the "leading estate of Russia," the bulwark of the monarchy organized as a system of estates. Liberals, hoping for a gradual fundamental regeneration of the nobility and the possibility that it would share its privileges with the bourgeoisie, and who, for this reason, understated the role and significance of the nobility in every way, were also compelled to admit that the marshals' positions had not been weakened. But they believed that the marshals held these posts not as representatives of their estate but as government officials. Thus, A. D. Gradovskii asserted that "if the nobility retains its importance in the state even today, that is due to a totally extraneous circumstance, to wit, because of the offices of province [guberniia] and district [uezd] marshals of the nobility. (3) Despite this high evaluation of the post of marshal - apparently deriving not so much from the degree to which the question had been studied as from practical knowledge of the matter - the authors dealing with this subject usually confined themselves only to listing the range of duties of the office falling within the jurisdiction of the marshals and established in law. Moreover, the legal documents defining the status of the marshals were regarded by these writers simply as a manifestation of "royal favor" with respect to the highest estate, which was totally in accord with the dominant official position that the monarchy was above classes.