Current Sociology · 2015 · 108 citations · 31 references
Social SciencesAnthropologySociologyAsian StudiesHindu StudiesSocial InequalityHinduismIndian StudiesMedieval IndiaSocial StratificationSouth Asian HistorySouth Asian StudiesCaste HistoryCaste InequalityCaste OppressionCaste PoliticsCaste-based InequalityCaste-like StratificationOrientalist CritiqueSocial Stratification Analysis
Caste is often portrayed as a uniquely Hindu institution rooted in tradition, expected to disappear with modernization, and this perspective limits its applicability to other societies. The article argues that the prevailing view of caste rests on Indian exceptionalism and proposes that newer theories can offer comparative tools for studying social inequalities.
Social science literature on caste tends to view it as a peculiar institution of the Hindus, emanating from their past tradition and religious beliefs/scriptures. This view also presumes that the processes of urbanization and industrialization, unleashing the process of modernization, will end caste, eventually producing a shift from a closed system of social hierarchy to an open system of social stratification based on individual achievement, merit and hard work. Drawing from a large volume of recent writings the author argues in this article that this approach to the understanding of caste is based on an assumption of Indian exceptionalism. Such an orientalist view of caste also denies the possibility of deploying the framework of caste for understanding caste-like ascriptive hierarchies that exist in many other (if not all) societies. Some of the recent theorizations of caste could perhaps provide useful conceptual tools for developing a comparative understanding of social inequalities.
31
From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology
E. N., Hans H. Gerth, Charles W. Mills · The Journal of Philosophy · 1946 · 3.6K citations
On the Division of Labor in Society
C. E. Gehlke, Émile Durkheim, George Gaylord Simpson · Columbia Law Review · 1935 · 3.3K citations
Homo Hierarchicus: The Caste System and Its Implications.
Gerald D. Berreman, Louis Dumont · Man · 1971 · 2.3K citations
Castes of Mind: Colonialism and the Making of Modern India
Lucian W. Pye, Nicholas B. Dirks · Foreign Affairs · 2002 · 1.4K citations