Western Bantu Tradition and the Notion of Tradition

Jan Vansina

Paideuma · 1989 · 18 citations · 7 references

Concepts

Abstract

The concept of tradition is central to anthropology. Oddly enough, however, anthropologists use the noun itself much less than the adjective 'traditional'. 'Tradition' in a subsidiary meaning for the Encyclopaedia Britannica 191 A (15th ed.) is the aggregate of customs, beliefs and practices that give continuity to culture, civilization or social group and thus shape its views. Taken in this sense laws and institutions are also part of 'tradition'. 'Traditional' is often used as shorthand for 'old, unchanging'. The concept 'tradition' itself in the sense of 'long established opinion, custom or practice' seems to be of French origin and even there it is a derived meaning. Quillet gives the definition: 'The transmission of knowledge, religious doctrine or, by extension, of human knowledge, of facts, customs etc. from generation to generation' and as a second meaning, 'each item thus transmitted' (Auge, 1900, Lalande, 1972; Quillet, 1959). The meaning 'in English' long established customs or practice' (Webster, 1978) is a derived one, usually applied to the arts and less common than the meaning 'oral transmission over generations'. Although the concept is central to anthropology it has not been explored much since A. Kroeber although recently a spate of works have appeared on the 'invention of tradition'. Kroeber (1948: 253-254) defined 'tradition' as 'social inheritance' and saw it as the distinctive feature of culture itself. Tradition consists of 'all kinds of things': speech, knowledge, activities, rules and the rest 'and culture consists of the learning of tradition, for tradition is also the transmission of culture over time as a template (1948: 41 1). But Kroeber's discussion was not followed up by cultural anthropologists despite the fact that tradition implicitly lies at the heart of descriptions of the 'beliefs and customs of the so and so' and even more at the heart of studies about 'culture areas, provinces' or 'circles'. Only among archaeologists has the notion been further elaborated (Willey, 1953: 373-374) especially by J. Steward. His theory of 'cultural core' (1955: 37) remains the predominant view in that field. For him cultures exhibit a stable core of features most closely related to subsistence activities and economic arrangements. This continuity defines their tradition. His critics fault him, not only for his use of evolutionary theory in matters of culture, but also because his criteria for establishing cultural cores were not constant. It was felt in a general way that the whole concept of 'tradition? is too vague to use. We cannot let the discussion rest there. Clearly crucial continuities exist in culture and in social systems and to ignore them because they are 'too vague' is unwarranted. It is time to reopen the question. One way to do this is to examine a complex concrete case, that of the Western Bantu tradition and use the results to reflect on the nature and the characteristics of the phenomenon one calls tradition.

References

7