Early failure of metal-on-metal bearings in hip resurfacing and large-diameter total hip replacement

David Langton, Simon Jameson, TJ Joyce, Nadim J. Hallab, Sonali Natu, A. V. F. Nargol

Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery - British Volume · 2010 · 736 citations · 37 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Early failure due to adverse reactions to metal debris is an emerging problem after hip resurfacing, and its absence in well‑positioned implants suggests high component wear. The study analyzed 660 metal‑on‑metal hip resurfacings and large‑bearing ASR total hip replacements to identify associations with metal‑debris‑related failures and to guide surgeons in implant design, component size, and acetabular positioning to reduce early failures. The authors examined clinical and radiological outcomes, measured metal ion levels, performed explant studies, and conducted lymphocyte transformation tests on the series of 660 metal‑on‑metal hip resurfacings and large‑bearing ASR total hip replacements. Seventeen patients (3.4%) required revision for adverse reactions to metal debris, and these cases had smaller components, higher acetabular anteversion, elevated chromium and cobalt ion concentrations, no lymphocyte reactivity post‑revision, and greater surface wear on explants compared to uncomplicated fracture retrievals.

Abstract

Early failure associated with adverse reactions to metal debris is an emerging problem after hip resurfacing but the exact mechanism is unclear. We analysed our entire series of 660 metal-on-metal resurfacings (Articular Surface Replacement (ASR) and Birmingham Hip Resurfacing (BHR)) and large-bearing ASR total hip replacements, to establish associations with metal debris-related failures. Clinical and radiological outcomes, metal ion levels, explant studies and lymphocyte transformation tests were performed. A total of 17 patients (3.4%) were identified (all ASR bearings) with adverse reactions to metal debris, for which revision was required. This group had significantly smaller components, significantly higher acetabular component anteversion, and significantly higher whole concentrations of blood and joint chromium and cobalt ions than asymptomatic patients did (all p < 0.001). Post-revision lymphocyte transformation tests on this group showed no reactivity to chromium or cobalt ions. Explants from these revisions had greater surface wear than retrievals for uncomplicated fractures. The absence of adverse reactions to metal debris in patients with well-positioned implants usually implies high component wear. Surgeons must consider implant design, expected component size and acetabular component positioning in order to reduce early failures when performing large-bearing metal-on-metal hip resurfacing and replacement.

References

37