Election Law Journal Rules Politics and Policy · 2015 · 108 citations · 17 references
Social SciencesConstitutional LawPolitical ScienceAmerican PoliticsElectoral PoliticsLegislative PoliticsElectionsElectoral DistrictingLegislative PolarizationParty IdentificationState Legislative PoliticsVoting BehaviorCongressional RedistrictingCourt-legislature RelationsDistricting CriteriaGerrymandering DetectionLegislative ObjectivesPartisan BiasPartisan RepresentationState Legislative Districting
Social scientists have made progress in providing the courts with useful measures of partisan asymmetry in the transformation of votes to seats, but have thus far left a larger question unanswered: how can partisan gerrymandering be distinguished from a state legislature's acceptable efforts to apply traditional districting criteria, keep communities of interest together, and facilitate the representation of minorities? This article demonstrates how a straightforward redistricting algorithm can be used to generate a benchmark against which to contrast a plan that has been called into constitutional question, thus laying bare any partisan advantage that cannot be attributed to legitimate legislative objectives. We use the controversial 2012 Florida Congressional map to show how our approach can be used to demonstrate an unconstitutional gerrymander.
17
A Question of Place: Exploring the Practice of Human Geography
James Bird, Ron Johnston · Geographical Journal · 1993 · 176 citations
On the Prevention of Gerrymandering
William Vickrey · Political Science Quarterly · 1961 · 134 citations