Renaissance and Reformation · 1969 · 17 citations · 1 references
HumanitiesReligionReligious StudiesLiterary CriticismRhetoricRhetorical StudiesBiblical ExegesisClassical RhetoricPoeticsRhetoric Of ReligionRhetorical TheorySacred TextsClassical Rhetorical TheoryDoctrinal ChangeRhetoric Of ScriptureRhetoric Of The ProphetsSacred EncounterSonnet Theory
sonnet beginning "At the round earths imagined corners"fourth in Dame Helen Gardner's numbering of Donne's Holy Sonnets, ^seventh in Sir Herbert Grierson'shas had almost as distinguished a career in the lists of commentary as in the civil quiet of anthologies. LA. Richards used it for his Cambridge experiments in Practical Criticism, where it attracted the highest number of non-committal "votes."^It figures importantly in Dame Helen's account of the Holy Sonnets as illustrative of Donne's progress in doctrinal matters and of his Ignatian method in composition. It is analysed by Stanley Archer in his questioning of the relevance of that method to an understanding of Dome's poems, and employed by Murray Roston as an instance of Donne 's mannerism. It is, for Wilbur Sanders, "eloquently modulated" and "spine-tingling" (perhaps the Holly woodism is half-way to dispraise), t ut finally not the product of "a genuinely religious encounter."^More evidence could be added to quaUfy Richards' observationupon revie\^tng student proto- cols on the sonnetthat "It is in the nature of some performances that they leave the spectator feeling rather helpless."
1
A Study of the Prose Works of John Donne.
Edwin Greenlaw, Evelyn Simpson, Mario Praz et al. · Modern Language Notes · 1928 · 40 citations