The Open Field System and Beyond

Carl J. Dahlman

Cambridge University Press eBooks · 1980 · 222 citations · 0 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The book tackles criticisms of applying economic theory to historical problems, appealing to agrarian and economic historians and medieval specialists. The study aims to apply modern economic methodology to the historical problem of the ancient English open field system. The authors employ contemporary economic analysis to reinterpret the open field system as a rational adaptation to production and historical conditions. The analysis shows that the open field system’s scattered strips and common lands served vital economic functions, overturning the view of it as inefficient, and offers general insights into institutional theory that challenge deterministic interpretations.

Abstract

In this book, Professor Dahlman applies modern economic methodology to an old historical problem. He demonstrates how the quaint institutions of the ancient English open field system of agriculture can be understood as an intelligent and rational adaptation to a particular problem of production and to certain historical circumstances. He argues that the two major characteristics of this type of agriculture - scattered strips owned by individual peasants and extensive areas of common land - both fulfilled vital economic functions. This overturns the traditional view of the open field system as inefficient and rigidly bound by tradition, and throws light on the behaviour of medeival peasants. Professor Dahlman also offers some generalisations about the economic theory of institutions and institutional change, refuting the idea that an economic analysis of institutions must necessarily be deterministic. As a challenge to some of the fundamental criticisms of the application of economic theory to historical problems, the book will be of great interest to agrarian historians and to economic historians generally, as well as to specialists in the medieval period.