Molecular Biology and Evolution · 2015 · 104 citations · 78 references
Life SciencesBiologyZoologyComparative GenomicsEvolutionary EcologyMolecular EvolutionBird EvolutionNatural SelectionOlfactory PhysiologyOlfactory SystemsReptile BiologySensory BiologyLineage-specific GenesOlfactory Receptor BiologyOlfactory Receptor FunctionOlfactory Receptor Gene FamilyPositive SelectionSea Turtle BiologySensory System EvolutionTaxon-specific Gene Repertoires
Olfactory receptors (ORs) govern a prime sensory function. Extant birds have distinct olfactory abilities, but the molecular mechanisms underlining diversification and specialization remain mostly unknown. We explored OR diversity in 48 phylogenetic and ecologically diverse birds and 2 reptiles (alligator and green sea turtle). OR subgenomes showed species- and lineage-specific variation related with ecological requirements. Overall 1,953 OR genes were identified in reptiles and 16,503 in birds. The two reptiles had larger OR gene repertoires (989 and 964 genes, respectively) than birds (182-688 genes). Overall, birds had more pseudogenes (7,855) than intact genes (1,944). The alligator had significantly more functional genes than sea turtle, likely because of distinct foraging habits. We found rapid species-specific expansion and positive selection in OR14 (detects hydrophobic compounds) in birds and in OR51 and OR52 (detect hydrophilic compounds) in sea turtle, suggestive of terrestrial and aquatic adaptations, respectively. Ecological partitioning among birds of prey, water birds, land birds, and vocal learners showed that diverse ecological factors determined olfactory ability and influenced corresponding olfactory-receptor subgenome. OR5/8/9 was expanded in predatory birds and alligator, suggesting adaptive specialization for carnivory. OR families 2/13, 51, and 52 were correlated with aquatic adaptations (water birds), OR families 6 and 10 were more pronounced in vocal-learning birds, whereas most specialized land birds had an expanded OR family 14. Olfactory bulb ratio (OBR) and OR gene repertoire were correlated. Birds that forage for prey (carnivores/piscivores) had relatively complex OBR and OR gene repertoires compared with modern birds, including passerines, perhaps due to highly developed cognitive capacities facilitating foraging innovations.
78
CONFIDENCE LIMITS ON PHYLOGENIES: AN APPROACH USING THE BOOTSTRAP
Joseph Felsenstein · Evolution · 1985 · 41.5K citations · Full text
Koichiro Tamura, Daniel G. Peterson, Nora Peterson et al. · Molecular Biology and Evolution · 2011 · 40.3K citations · Full text
Confidence Limits on Phylogenies: An Approach Using the Bootstrap
Joseph Felsenstein · Evolution · 1985 · 19.3K citations
Non‐parametric multivariate analyses of changes in community structure
K.R. Clarke · Australian Journal of Ecology · 1993 · 14.1K citations