Ceremonial Budgeting: Public Participation in Development Planning at an Indonesian Local Government Authority

Ana Sopanah

2012 · 23 citations · 4 references

Concepts

Abstract

AbstractThe purpose of this case study is to explain how public participation (Musrenbang) in planning was practiced at the Local Government level in East Java, Indonesia. Public participation is a process of planning in which citizens are involved in proposing and planning projects to ensure fruitful implementation. The research is based on an interpretive paradigm, using the technique of phenomenology analysis to explore the effect of participation on local government budgeting. It was found that although most participation mechanisms followed existing policies and regulations in terms of 'form' the 'substance' of the regulation was lacking. It was seen that that participation in local government budgeting is still assumed to be merely a formality, done as part of a required ceremony to fulfil certain local government obligations. The budgetary process is mostly ceremonial because only certain members of the public can access information about the purpose of the program, i.e. there is low socialisation by the wider community of stakeholders.Key Words:Public ParticipationLocal BudgetingLocal GovernmentBudgeting ProcessMusrenbangPhenomenologyIntroductionIn the last decade, with demand for transparency, the issues of good governance have been hotly debated. From the government's point of view, this equates to the use of public resources more efficiently and effectively (Osborne dan Gaebler, 1992; Barzelay, 1992; Cohen and Brand, 1993; Sumarto, 2004; Sukardi, 2009). From the citizen's point of view, this equates to more public participation in organising public affairs including local government planning and budgeting (Callahan, 2002; Ebdon, 2002; Muluk, 2007; Syarifudin, 2010; Razak, 2011).Since reformation in Indonesia, the term governance and the term participation have become well-known. Almost all activities of local government have the term 'participative' embedded: i.e. approach, development and so on. However, although the word has become common, the real meaning of the term participative appears to have been forgotten.Public participation in formulating local budgets (termed Musrenbang in the Indonesian context)1 is defined in various regulations, including the 2004 law no. 32 and 33 on Local Government and the Financial Balance between the Central and Local Governments; the 2007 Domestic Minister Regulation No. 59 on the Changes of the Domestic Minister Regulation no.13 on the Manual on the Local Financial Management; the 2004 Law no. 25 on the National Development Planning; and the Joint Letter between the National Planning Board and the Domestic Minister no. 1354/M.PPN/ 03/2004050/744/SJ on the Manual for the Implementation of Musyawarah Perencanaan Pembangunan (Musrenbang) forum and Local Participative Planning (a full list of Regulation is provided in the Appendix).The meaning of the various regulations above is that the people may be involved in the planning process, in the implementation, and in the accountability of any that uses funds from local budgets. However, prior research indicates that 'actual' public participation is still low and that citizens rarely take part in the full Musrenbang process. For example, Sopanah (2003, 2004, 2005a,b and 2008) confirms that while public participation in the local budgeting is encouraged by various regulations, in fact actual participation is still very low and ineffective.Other research about public participation in the process of establishing public policies in other countries also confirm these Indonesian findings; i.e.public participation is low (see, Cooper and Elliot, 2000; Layzer, 2002; Navaro, 2002; Adams; 2004). The evidence was mainly visual, often shown by the low level of attendance at various public gatherings and stakeholder meetings. However, the general consensus was that although such public gatherings are considered to be less effective as a tool for rational persuasion, they still help to maintain the perception of a local democratic system at work. …

References

4