Australasian Journal on Ageing · 2015 · 16 citations · 3 references
Public AffairsHealth PolicyPublic BudgetingAging PolicyFiscal PolicyGerontologyIntergenerational PolicyOld-age Income SecurityPension PolicyPopulation AgingRetirement PolicyRetirement Security PolicyAgeing-related Fiscal PressuresAging-related Fiscal PressuresGovernment Health ExpenditurePension PressurePublic Pension PolicyRetirement Age ReformRetirement Policy ReformRetirement Tax Policy
While Australia has one of the most efficient healthcare systems in the world, Leaders agreed that health is a top priority for all levels of government with a serious funding challenge made more difficult by our ageing population. In the August National Reform Summit 2, our ageing population again emerged centre stage as the cause of increasing pressure on some government services, especially pensions and aged care, with rising health care expenditure also being a major concern. The Summit statement also devoted considerable attention to the development of a sustainable retirement incomes policy, noting that there are deep challenges that have the potential to compromise its effectiveness and sustainability. This is not the first time that our older Australians have been identified as being responsible for the fiscal doom that we are apparently facing 3. Indeed, this has been a common theme in all four of the Commonwealth's Intergenerational Reports (IGRs), the latest of which was released earlier this year 4. As the IGR is the centrepiece of the Australian Government's forward looking demographic, economic and fiscal projections, it is timely to revisit IGR 2015 4 to see what it said, to assess its worth and to uncover the spin. Towards the end of the great reform era of the 1990s, the Commonwealth Parliament passed a law which created a Charter of Budget Honesty. Its purpose was ‘to improve fiscal policy outcomes’. With a name like that, however, and given the fiscal outcomes of the last five years, it is not surprising that the Charter's reports need to be looked at closely. One of the Charter's requirements is that the Treasurer (note, a minister of the Government, not an independent agency) is to publicly release, at least once every five years, an IGR. But where does the focus on ageing come from? An intergenerational report is to assess the long term sustainability of current Government policies over the 40 years following the release of the report, including by taking account of the financial implications of demographic change. 5 However, the better answer is that ageing really is one of the many important considerations for Governments when making policy decisions and framing annual budgets. Any number of reports published over the last two decades, including the four IGRs 4, 6-8, have made the point that Australia's population is ageing and that there will be budgetary and economic consequences. Some of the more balanced commentators also make the point that there are social benefits from this ageing, such as a rich and growing pool of experience and wisdom that is now increasingly available to local communities. And some go further, to acknowledge the personal benefits of living longer and healthier lives! What's more, many of the fitter and more engaged older Australians even want to remain in the workforce, pay income tax, save for their self-funded retirement and support the economy. It is fantastic that Australians are living longer and healthier lives but we need to address these demographic changes. If we don't do something, we risk reducing our available workforce, impacting negatively on growth and prosperity, and our income will come under increasing pressure. [p.iii] The IGR restates the now well-accepted fact that we are living longer and will continue to have one of the longest life expectancies in the world. In 40 years' time, life expectancy at birth is projected to be nearly 97 for women and a little less for men. This is an increase of three or more years compared to those born in 2015. By 2045, around 2 million Australians are projected to be over 85 years and 40 000 would be centenarians (there were only 122 in the mid-1970s). The projections are for fewer people in what is currently the traditional working age group (15–64) for every person aged 65 and older. The ratio would decline from 4.5:1 now to 2.7:1 in 2054–55. This is important, as it is those who are in the working age group who generate most of the income tax, which helps pay for government services, including public health and hospital care, aged care and the age pension. A reducing proportion of the population in the workforce would also mean lower economic growth. And in general, the larger the economy (especially in per capita terms), the greater the employment and the more the country can afford good quality public services. The biggest item of budgetary increase over the next 40 years, unsurprisingly, is health, and older Australians, per head, are much greater consumers of health services than younger Australians. As a proportion of the economy (gross domestic production or GDP), Australian Government health expenditure is projected to increase from 4.2 per cent of GDP to 5.5 per cent by 2054–55. (In 2013–14, total expenditure on health by all governments, individuals and the non-government sector represented 9.8 per cent of GDP 9. Expenditure by the Australian Government on aged care services is projected to almost double, from the current 0.9 per cent of GDP to 1.7 per cent. Expenditure on age and service pensions is projected to largely stabilise at a little lower than the current 2.9 per cent of GDP. In itself, population ageing should not be seen as a problem, but it will give rise to economic and fiscal impacts that pose significant policy challenges. The [IGR] report explains how non-demographic factors, including higher incomes, health sector wages growth and technological change, are more significant drivers of the projected increase than demographic changes. More cost-effective service provision, especially in health care, would alleviate a major source of fiscal pressure at its source. As noted, the IGR is produced by the Treasurer, not by an objective government agency. Many commentators have drawn attention to the highly political presentation of IGR 2015 4 (even though all four IGR reports have had some spin from the Treasurer of the day). The IGR projections assert that, because government expenditure rises with age, population ageing would increase expenditure, and this ‘requires cuts’ of government expenditure. In particular, the report contains some big scary charts and numbers. Remember, this report came out after the release of the 2014–15 Budget 11 and was written for an obstructionist Senate and for the support of public sentiment. The rapidly escalating lines and big numbers all belong to what is called ‘previous policy’. For that, read ‘the Coalition Government's interpretation of the previous Labor Government's fiscal position’ – though it includes many decisions of the Coalition when they first came to power. Not surprisingly, similar arguments were also advanced by the first Howard Government when it can to power and sought to reign in Labor debt even before IGR1. In IGR 2015 4, the moderately rising lines and less big numbers belong to ‘currently legislated’ decisions. For that, read the things in the 2014–15 Budget 11 that the Senate had agreed to. The gentle sloping lines and moderate numbers are the ‘proposed policy’, which include all the other parts of the 2014–15 11 Budget, such as the CPI indexation of the age pension, that were stuck in the Senate and had not yet been (nor, largely, ever will be) passed by the Parliament. Using some highly contested assumptions, the Treasurer's report projects that under the ‘proposed policy’, Australian Government net debt would fall from the current level of 15.2 per cent of GDP to zero by 2031–32 and then move into surplus. Does this sound eerily familiar? The surplus is coming – we just have to wait a little longer. This is a report that is only about the Australian Government's Budget. As such, it is not very helpful, when you remember that public hospitals (and also education, community services, police and many other public goods and services) are largely paid for by the states. For health in particular, one of the reasons that the Australian Government's health expenditure is not projected to rise by more than shown in IGR 2015 4 is that the then Treasurer, in his 2014–15 Budget 11, announced that from 2017, the Commonwealth was walking away from the previous agreement to contribute to the long-term growth in hospital costs. It is no wonder that, at the Leaders' Retreat, the NSW Premier made a presentation that highlighted the growing gap facing all states on health and hospital funding. As was again demonstrated in the August Reform Summit Statement, the problem has not gone away; the Australian Government has merely transferred the problem to the states. This raises the obvious point – this report should be about all public spending and revenue – the Commonwealth, the states and their local governments. Again, the Productivity Commission's 2005 Report, and its 2013 update 10, 12, managed to do this, and to be much more transparent than the IGR about the assumptions behind the modelling. New Zealand goes one further and makes its model publicly available so that any analyst can test and report on the outcome from other assumptions. The IGRs have argued that solutions to Government's fiscal challenges rest on the three Ps – population, participation and productivity. Population growth generally increases the size of the economy and government revenue, but also increases the demand for public expenditure and raises other social and environmental costs. Increased workforce participation, including strategies for working longer, benefits the economy and taxpayers, and generally benefits the individual workers. Looking ahead, however, it is productivity growth that is the long-term solution to growing the economy and being able to pay for the rising costs of services that older people and everyone else will be needing. Health-care costs are manageable with proactive policy adjustments as outlined by Duckett in the parallel editorial 13. These are where the main policy challenges really lie. The IGR, in its current format, should be replaced with a much more objective, transparent and whole-of-government report to the Australian public on a baseline fiscal, economic and social outlook over the longer term, based on current policy settings. Only then will we have a document that can serve as a platform for debating a real agenda of productivity reforms that will meet our looming policy challenges.
3
Economic Implications of an Ageing Australia
Productivity Commission · SSRN Electronic Journal · 2005 · 217 citations · Full text
Shayne Neumann · 2010 · 181 citations
2015 Intergenerational Report Australia in 2055
J. B. Hockey · 2015 · 123 citations