The International Journal of African Historical Studies · 2015 · 68 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesDevelopment StudiesPolitical SciencePolitical Economy Of DevelopmentPolitical SociologyPostcolonial Development StudiesAfrican PoliticsDemocracyPolitical RegimesPostcolonial African StatesElite Political CultureLocal ElitesPolitical Elite BehaviorPolitical Elite TheoryPostcolonial Nation-buildingPostcolonial State PoliticsRural ElitesTanzania History
Government of Development: Peasants and Politicians in Postcolonial Tanzania. By Leander Schneider. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2014. Pp. viii, 234; illustrations, maps, notes, bibliography. $75.00 cloth, $28.00 paper.As Government of Development was published in 2014, media and political life in Tanzania were consumed by allegations that very highly placed government officials looted vast sums from an escrow account established by government. Convincing Tanzanians these days that their government is good at anything other than facilitating theft by a political elite is tough sledding. Nevertheless, at this inauspicious moment Leander Schneider has made a persuasive case against the view that government serves the narrow material interests of particular elites. He makes his case by examining the government of Julius Nyerere during the 1960s and 1970s. One comes away from this book wondering whether the Tanzanian state has changed fundamentally since the 1970s, or whether the view that the state functions primarily in the service of a political elite is as illusory now as it was, according to Schneider, in the 1970s.Government of Development focuses on the campaign to resettle Tanzania's rural population in ujamaa villages. It is not a social history of ujamaa, but rather a tightly conceived study of the policies and actions of government. Like all studies of postcolonial Tanzania, it is affected by the limitations of the available documentary record, and in particular by the lack of availability of the papers of President Nyerere and most records of the ruling party. Nevertheless, the author uses an impressive range of sources to argue that the officials who implemented government policy shared a desire to defend their special status as experts in development; that in other respects, however, their interests, perceptions, and purposes were diverse; and that this diversity of commitments constituted a historically specific assemblage of discourses and practices that could be harnessed fully neither by any individual-even one as willful and intimidating as President Nyerere-nor by any social class or elite.The study begins with two chapters on the Ruvuma Development Association, an episode in rural resettlement whose origins predate ujamaa. Schneider argues that because RDA villages were settled by volunteers, they provided Nyerere with a model of how agrarian society could be reorganized inexpensively by governing through freedom. Although the RDA inspired Nyerere, argues Schneider, it was closed down by government and party officials who were offended by the lack of deference shown them by RDA leaders. …