Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies · 1997 · 40 citations · 0 references
HumanitiesHistoryMedieval StudiesAsian StudiesMedieval LiteratureTextual CriticismEast Asian StudiesSacred TextsFemale Subject FormationPossession In Spirit MediumsPrimary SourcesSpirit Possession Healing
kuai reports of spirit possession (pp. 10-12), poltergeists (pp. 133-34), etc. It remains debatable whether such assumptions are necessary, or even useful, for the successful use of hsiao-shuo texts as windows into the lives of medieval men and women. There is no question of Dudbridge's estimable erudition: his knowledge of T'ang history and texts is superlative, and his use of primary sources is meticulous. Yet, some of his methods and conclusions here may seem curious even to scholars who share his general goals. Today's chih-kuai specialists, in particular, may find them rather disappointing. Scholars like Campany and Zeitlin have now published sophisticated analyses of chih-kuai collections from various periods. Oddly, Dudbridge makes limited use of much recent scholarship, including an indispensable 1985 study by Karl Kao, which is mentioned only in passing. Similarly, voices of T'ang women have been heard in recent studies by Cahill and others. Dudbridge seems to have overlooked those and other pertinent studies that might have aided his efforts. In any event, specialists will find much of value in this book.