Building Energy Code Compliance in Developing Countries: The Potential Role of Outcomes-Based Codes in India

Meredydd Evans, Mark A. Halverson, Alison Delgado, Sha Yu

2014 · 11 citations · 5 references

Concepts

Abstract

Developing countries are witnessing tremendous growth in their building stock, which is putting pressure on power and other energy systems. India is an excellent example of this growth, and of increasing efforts to implement requirements to reduce building energy use. India’s building energy code, the Energy Conservation Building Code (ECBC), addresses issues such as the building’s thermal envelope, lighting systems, HVAC systems, electrical systems, water heating and fluid pumping systems. We know that building design and construction affect actual building performance, but factors such as user behavior, occupancy patterns, commissioning and maintenance also play a major role. Building energy codes focus only on design and construction because in developed countries, existing permitting processes provide a framework for influencing efficiency. Developing countries, on the other hand, may have weak, ineffective building permitting systems. Like many developing countries, India is considering expanding implementation of its building energy code and using performance metrics to enhance or substitute for enforcement of the building energy code. In most of India, ECBC is currently voluntary, and significant enforcement gaps remain. Can performance metrics, such as energy use compared to a benchmark, help speed implementation of the building code? What would such a system look like? In short, are outcomes-based codes a viable option in developing countries with limited resources? This paper compares traditional and outcomes-based compliance pathways for a building energy code, explores approaches to integrating outcomes-based codes with traditional ECBC implementation and discusses specific issues in implementing outcomes-based codes such as benchmarking, incentives, measurement and verification. Given their novelty, it is difficult to recommend that India or other developing economies adopt outcomes-based codes alone. Rather, if governments would like to promote energy efficiency in actual building performance and have adequate resources, they might consider implementing both a traditional and an outcomes-based code system.

References

5