How is Bitcoin Money?

Ole Bjerg

Theory Culture & Society · 2015 · 115 citations · 28 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Bitcoin is a peer‑to‑peer electronic payment system that operates as an independent currency. The paper philosophically investigates Bitcoin’s ontological constitution. Using Žižek’s ontological triad, the authors compare Bitcoin to commodity, fiat, and credit money to analyze its constitution. The authors conclude Bitcoin is commodity money without gold, fiat money without a state, and credit money without debt, thereby challenging conventional money by exposing exploitation, risk, and violence inherent in state‑authorized credit systems.

Abstract

Bitcoin is a peer-to-peer electronic payment system that operates as an independent currency. This paper is a philosophical investigation of the ontological constitution of Bitcoin. Using Slavoj Žižek’s ontological triad of the real, the symbolic and the imaginary, the paper distinguishes between three ideal typical theories of money: commodity theory, fiat theory, and credit theory. The constitution of Bitcoin is analysed by comparing the currency to each of these ideal types. It is argued that Bitcoin is commodity money without gold, fiat money without a state, and credit money without debt. In conclusion, it is suggested that Bitcoin poses an ideological challenge to conventional forms of money in so far as it not only provokes sedimented beliefs about money but also exposes the forms of exploitation, risk and even violence inherent in the existing system of state authorized credit money.

References

28