Residents' Perceptions of Community and Environmental Impacts From Development of Natural Gas in the Marcellus Shale: A Comparison of Pennsylvania and New York Cases

TLDR

Communities experiencing rapid growth from energy development report both positive and negative impacts on well‑being, with perceptions varying by development stage and prior extractive experience. The authors use the Marcellus Shale development as a case to examine these impacts over time and across geographic and historical contexts through case‑study research in Pennsylvania and New York. The study compares sites with differing development levels and prior extractive history, using case‑study methods that incorporate regional historical context. In low‑density areas, higher development levels increase awareness of natural‑gas impacts, both positive and negative.

Abstract

Communities experiencing rapid growth due to energy development (‘boomtowns’) have reported positive and negative impacts on community and individual well-being. The perceptions of impacts vary according to stage of energy development as well as experience with extractive industries. Development of the Marcellus Shale provides an opportunity to examine these impacts over time and across geographic and historical contexts. This paper describes case study research in Pennsylvania and New York to document preliminary impacts of development occurring there. Cases vary by level of development and previous extractive history. The study finds that, in areas with low population density, higher levels of development lead to a broader awareness of natural gas impacts, both positive and negative. Participants draw from the regional history of