Doing Educational Research in Rural Settings: Methodological Issues, International Perspectives and Practical Solutions

Ian Burfoot‐Rochford

Journal of Research in Rural Education · 2015 · 69 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Book Review White, S., & Corbett, M. (Eds.) (2014). Doing educational research in settings: Methodological issues, international perspectives and practical solutions. New York, NY: Routledge.Doing Educational Research in Rural Settings: Methodological Issues, International Perspectives and Practical Solutions, edited by Simone White and Michael Corbett, provides an introduction to education research and represents one of the first books to address the many methodological issues that emerge in this research. Collectively, the authors argue that education research must hono r and reveal that which is distinctive about schools and communities and the interrelationship between them. To do otherwise inevitably marginalizes places as deficient, thus undermining their vitality and uniqueness. As the authors in this collection make clear, conducting research for, rather than simply places is of critical importance. Therefore, the research process should be shaped accordingly. Like many anthologies, this collection covers a range of diverse issues and themes that are not always consistently presented in a way that best serves the reader. In this book review, I highlight the palpable themes that emerged from the text, although the book does not follow this structure.How Rural Places and Schools Are UnderstoodIn the first chapter, Craig and Aimee Howley provide a useful critique of dominant social thought, methodologies, and research practices that are often applied to schools and communities: Hegemonic educational and social discourses frequently marginalize ways of life and conceptualize education as problematic. Metrocentricity, common in modern discourse, effectively pushes places and practices to the margins of contemporary thinking. Other contributors to this volume discuss how this marginalization occurs over space and scale (Green & Reid), in theory application (Gristy; Kvalsund & Hargreaves), in teaching (Roberts), through the metaphorical misrepresentation of rural (Donehower), and in public policy (Bartholemaeus, Halsey, & Corbett). For example, Rune Kvalsund and Linda Hargreaves show how a mass-society perspective derived from Giddens' contemporary social theory ultimately devalues life and thus places the researcher in opposition to the people and practices under study. How places and schools are conceptualized and constructed within these research paradigms can narrow and skew how schools and communities are understood, thereby unknowingly continuing to marginalize and disempower places, practices, and voices. Collectively, these researchers call for more critical evaluations, discussions, and reflections on the dominant theories and perspectives in the field in relation to their application to research on communities and education.The Researcher and the ParticipantBoth the positionality of the researcher and the relationship between researcher and participant are shaped by the need for education research to be for, rather than only on, places. In their trialogue, Pamela Bartholomaeus, John Halsey, and Michael Corbett highlight the challenges of objectivity in research. They emphasize the need for reflection, awareness, and disclosure of the positionality of the researcher before conducting research. Through this critical inventory, the researcher is able to understand his or her impact on the research process and specifically on his or her relationships with participants. Michelle Anderson and Michele Lonsdale argue how awareness of positionality becomes a critical steppingstone for respecting those studied while at the same time eliciting their viewpoints and understandings. As they state, Being attuned to our own assumptions and ideas means valuing difference, recognizing that ideas are unlikely to be shared if researchers aren't open to hearing them, and reflecting on the nature of the research enterprise itself (p. …