Évaluation de la demande de paysage: état de l’art et réflexions sur la méthode du transfert des bénéfices

Mbolatiana Rambonilaza

Cahiers d Economie et sociologie rurales · 2004 · 15 citations · 17 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Several studies have been published in the recent economic literature with the aim of assessing public landscape preferences. The main objectives of the present paper are : (1) to give an overview of the state of the art of the application of stated preferences method to landscape valuation and (2) to discuss the opportunity of benefit transfer. Firstly, landscape attributes may be either complements in utility. This is because they can be perceived as parts or not of the same scene. Thus, the evaluation problems raised by landscape conservation policies are multi-dimensional. In this context, because of the inclusion effect, the benefit of conserving attributes that are complements for consumers within a joint programme is smaller than the sum of the benefits of conserving them independently. If this is not the case, attributes are also complements in valuation that the joint benefit is higher than the sum of the individual benefits. Within the framework of ex-ante evaluation, introducing these interactions in values estimation needs the conversion of standard contingent valuation method into a multi-programmes approach or the use of choice experiments procedure. However, multi-programmes method only fits the sequential cost-benefit analysis to define optimal attribute-mix. Secondly, available benefit estimates are for the most obtained from standard approach. Although their transfer would not pose problem for an ex-post evaluation, landscape values are very sensitive to the natural, cultural and social conditions of the original surveys. Therefore, the use of meta-analysis method may offer the opportunity for transferring economic benefits within a very limited geographical and social contexts. Today, the existing studies are insufficient to cover a broad range of situations.

References

17