Human resources development for the operation of general practitioners' cluster

Karolina Kósa, János Sándor, Erik Dobos, M. Papp, Gergely Fürjes, R. Adany

European Journal of Public Health · 2013 · 17 citations · 0 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

As it was detailed in previous Viewpoints, Hungary has launched a new primary health care model programme in four small areas of the most disadvantaged regions of the country, aiming to reorient primary health care towards prevention with the long-term hope of not only improving the health status of the general population but also reducing social inequalities in health. In addition to services that they are competent to provide as licensed health workers, professionals working in the clusters will carry out activities that they have not at all or have not regularly done so far such as planning and implementing health promotion projects in the community, assessing the health status according to specific guidelines, counselling on lifestyle issues, assisting chronic care with rehabilitation focus. They work in a novel cluster-team in which mutually supportive collaboration and communication skills and attitudes are required. Therefore, special training with varying emphasis is needed to prepare all participants for work in the cluster. The ‘core training’ introduces the basics of the Programme, its aims, participants, organization, activities and publicly available documents on the details of the Programme. This module covers the fundamentals of internal and external communication as well, providing a basic understanding of the concept of the Programme to all professional participants. The ‘health promotion’ module will cover details to all professionals working at the cluster level on the development and organization of health promotion programmes in community settings. Community participation is a vital element of these programmes on which much has been published in the health promotion literature. Of them, the scheme on the degree of participation and accompanying toolbox—providing a range of methods for engagement and information sharing with the community to be involved—developed by the International Association for Public Participation1 was found to be the most useful to the general practitioners’ (GPs’) cluster program. The training raises awareness on the spectrum of participation, paving the way to better cooperation and group decision-making among health professionals, to increased desire and willingness of clients/patients to participate in the management of their own health and disease, and in general, to greater overall empowerment, fully in line with the call of the World Health Report 2008 for primary health care ‘in which people are partners in managing their own health and that of their community’. An additional feature of community programmes for which cluster workers need to be prepared is their ‘asset-based’ nature, as opposed to the more usual needs-based approach. Needs-based programme planning is driven by professionals after taking stock of scarcities, but much greater success can be achieved in deprived and marginalized communities if the point of departure is an inventory of available skills, resources and capacities.2 Asset-based planning, that is, considering the glass half-full rather than half-empty requires an uneasy shift in attitudes from health professionals and clients alike in Hungary, the most pessimistic country in the world.3 The ‘health assessment’ module will be mandatory for public health coordinators, public health specialists and community nurses to make them familiar with the organization, the various methods and equipments used for the assessment of health status of the clients of each practice. This module prepares these professionals for carrying out their tasks without the supervision of the GP. The ‘lifestyle counselling’ module will be focusing on improving health literacy, and the state-of-the-art methods of behavioural change at the primary care level targeting all those risk factors that have been established as determinants of the most frequent chronic diseases. Training will be offered to all professionals who are to engage in various forms of counselling in an individual or group setting. GPs provide this service in their offices individually for patients with established risk factors and/or diseases. The public health specialist, dietician, physiotherapist, health visitor and health psychologist provide individual and/or group counselling and health education outside the GP office to clients referred by the health assessment team and to patients referred by the GP. Lifestyle counselling and health education are the kinds of service the patients require most and get the least from their GPs, giving rise in greatest proportion to medical litigation. The ‘medical risk assessment’ training is offered specifically for GPs, while the ‘chronic care and rehabilitation’ is also provided to practice nurses, dieticians, physiotherapists and health psychologists to make them competent to use the relevant techniques/interventions in a concerted manner. Of the support workers, health mediators recruited from the local community are enrolled in vocational training to become nurse assistants or social care assistants subsequent to which they are to be employed as full-time workers to help health visitors in their field work, help recruit adults for health assessment and act as peer educators in their communities. Assistant health mediators will receive ad hoc training to prepare them for assisting the planning and implementation of health promoting programmes, facilitating the participation of the Roma people in the preventive programmes and improving patient-adherence and persistence. Support workers will be trained on the workings of the cluster by the public health coordinators. Their training will be built on lessons learned from a similar programme of the Open Society Institute.4 The training must also prepare non-medical health professionals for the ‘role of the independent health worker’, working without the continuous supervision of another professional, taking responsibility for decisions within their competence, making shared decisions with their colleagues and referring cases that are beyond their competence. This is a new role for all of them except health visitors who at present are the only primary health care workers besides the GPs to have their own workload, reporting only to the chief health visitor. A major aim of the training must be to establish convergent values and norms regarding the operation of the cluster, and to equip workers with means of communication that enable them to discuss and mitigate any problem that might arise. Another salient feature of this primary health care model is its preventive focus and its foundation on the ‘biopsychosocial model of health’. Learning to understand its value might be a challenge for doctors whose work is based on the biomedical model of health; they might even feel their livelihood threatened if too much emphasis is put on prevention. The training must ensure that the values of both models are seen by all, and that both models are needed if primary health care wants to fulfil not only its traditional role of providing care for the sick but also its new assignment of keeping people healthy and fully functioning within their potentials, preferably until the end of their lives. Written material for the training modules will be available online and upgraded regularly for continuous use by cluster workers. An internet-based questionnaire will be developed to enable professionals to provide feedback on their experiences and training needs. They will be requested to fill the questionnaire every 6 months; based on its results, additional material will be developed and/or face-to-face supervision sessions will be organized to share experiences and decide on further capacity building. Supervisory visits will be conducted at each cluster in the 6th and 12th months after completing the first training round, and in the 24th month of the Programme to identify areas of discontent and methods of addressing them. A simplified version of the online material for professionals along with printed material will be developed for stakeholders to obtain their support for the Programme. The model programme hopefully will not only lay the foundation for a prevention-oriented, people-centred new primary health care, but will also provide impetus for a shift in terms of public health training as well. Our hope is that the path towards medical specialization in public health will one day be open to not only medical doctors but to other health professionals as well, following the pioneer training model of the UK.5 The development of the model was made in the framework of the Swiss Contribution Programme SH/8/1. The project is supported by a grant from Switzerland through the Swiss Contribution. Conflicts of interest: None declared. The authors thank the participation of Eszter Sinkó, Sándor Balogh, Katalin Mária Dózsa, Rózsa Holló, József Rinfel, János Szabó, István Völgyi, Gábor Benkő, János Cséki, András Grósz, Tamás Gergely and Zita Dékán in the consultations.