DID "SERRANO" CAUSE PROPOSITION 13?

William A. Fischel

National Tax Journal · 1989 · 147 citations · 11 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Proposition 13 dramatically reduced California property taxes in 1978, a move many attribute to high government spending and rising homeowner tax burdens. The study argues that Proposition 13 reflects median voter preferences rather than Leviathan state theory. The Serrano decision severed the link between local property wealth and school funding, turning property taxes into a deadweight loss and prompting voters to reject the tax, thereby shifting school financing to the state.

Abstract

Proposition 13 gutted California's property tax system in 1978. Most people think that the tax-revolt initiative was caused by excessive government spending and rising tax burdens on homeowners. I argue that the California Supreme Court's landmark decision, Serrano v. Priest (1971), crippled the Tiebout system by divorcing local property wealth from school spending. Serrano thus converted most property taxes into a deadweight loss. Voters responded by rejecting the property tax, shifting the school finance burden to the state. My explanation supports the median voter model in contrast to Leviathan theories of state and local government.

References

11