Identity, Morals, and Taboos: Beliefs as Assets *

Roland Bénabou, Jean Tirole

The Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2011 · 1K citations · 64 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Identity investments respond nonmonotonically to acts or threats, and taboos on mere thoughts arise to protect beliefs about the priceless value of certain social assets. The study develops a theory of moral behavior, both individual and collective, grounded in a general identity model that links self‑concept to inferred values from past choices. The model posits that people care about who they are and infer their own values from past choices, forming the basis for moral behavior analysis. The model explains empirical puzzles, shows that high endowments trigger escalating commitment and a treadmill effect while competing identities cause dysfunctional capital destruction, and demonstrates that social interactions generate both social and antisocial contribution norms, sustained by shunning free riders or do‑gooders.

Abstract

We develop a theory of moral behavior, individual and collective, based on a general model of identity in which people care about “who they are” and infer their own values from past choices. The model sheds light on many empirical puzzles inconsistent with earlier approaches. Identity investments respond nonmonotonically to acts or threats, and taboos on mere thoughts arise to protect beliefs about the “priceless” value of certain social assets. High endowments trigger escalating commitment and a treadmill effect, while competing identities can cause dysfunctional capital destruction. Social interactions induce both social and antisocial norms of contribution, sustained by respectively shunning free riders or do-gooders.

References

64