American Journal of Sociology · 1978 · 421 citations · 33 references
Social SciencesPsychologySocial PsychologyChild DevelopmentDevelopmental PsychologySocial ComparisonDownward Social ComparisonSelf-esteemSelf-evaluation ProcessesSocial ClassSocializationCentralityComparison ProcessesPerception TheorySelf-perception TheorySocial Comparison Orientation
The literature on the relationship between social class and self‑esteem is contradictory, showing positive, null, and inverse associations. The authors propose four self‑esteem development principles—social comparison, reflected appraisals, self‑perception theory, and psychological centrality—to explain these conditional relations. They compared two studies, one of children aged 8–18 and one of adults aged 18–65, and applied the four principles to interpret the differing associations. The results show no association in younger children, a modest link in adolescents, and a moderate link in adults, and suggest that the four principles account for the age‑dependent effects of social class on self‑esteem.
The literature on the relationship of social class to self-esteem is riddled with contradictions, showing positive, null, and inverse relationships. Two studies examinig this relationship are compared-one, a sample of children aged 8-18; the other, a sample of adults aged 18-65. The results indicate virtually no association for younger children, a modest association for adolescents, and a moderate association for adults. Four principles of self-esteem development are advanced to account for these conditional relations-social comparison processes, reflected appraisals, self-perception theory, and psychological centrality. It is suggested that these principles apply equally to adults and children and that the identical principles help to explain why social class should have different effects on the self-esteem of children and adults.
33
A Theory of Social Comparison Processes
Léon Festinger · Human Relations · 1954 · 20.3K citations
Construct validity in psychological tests.
Lee J. Cronbach, Paul E. Meehl · Psychological Bulletin · 1955 · 10.9K citations · Full text
Social Theory and Social Structure
Eva J. Ross, Robert Κ. Merton · The American Catholic Sociological Review · 1958 · 10.4K citations
EQUALITY OF EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITY
James S. Coleman · Equity & Excellence in Education · 1968 · 5.3K citations
Social Theory and Social Structure.
Gregory P. Stone, Robert Κ. Merton · Administrative Science Quarterly · 1958 · 4.5K citations