Journal of Orthopaedic Research® · 2015 · 19 citations · 13 references
MedicineOrthopaedic SurgeryOrthopedic SurgeryOrthopaedic BiomaterialsOrthopedic BiomaterialsOrthopedicsHip ArthroplastyRadiographic AssessmentInter-examiner VariabilityOrthopaedic ImplantsPolyethylene ImplantsRadiographic Measurement Error AnalysisSockets
Although cemented all polyethylene (PE) cups have been routinely used in total hip arthroplasty for decades, no computer-assisted method for measurement of radiographic wear has ever been specifically validated for these implants. Using a validated hip phantom model, AP plain hip radiographs were obtained consecutively for eight simulated wear positions. A version of Martell's Hip Analysis Suite software dedicated to all polyethylene sockets was used by three different examiners of varied experience. Bias (mean, standard deviation and 95% confidence interval limit), repeatability (standard deviation and 95% limit) and reproducibility (standard deviation and 95% limit) for two-dimensional wear measurements were assessed, as recommended by the current ASTM guidelines. Using this protocol, the dedicated software showed an overall mean bias of 0.089 ± 0.060 mm (mean ± SD), and 0.118 mm for 95% CI limit. Repeatability (intra examiner) standard deviation and 95% limit were respectively 0.106 mm and 0.292 mm. Reproducibility (inter examiner) standard deviation and 95% limit were respectively 0.112 mm and 0.308 mm. Martell Hip Analysis for all PE cemented cups is a reliable and low-cost instrument in the assessment of wear, despite being less precise than its original version dedicated to cementless components.
13
W H Harris · PubMed · 1995 · 692 citations
Charles R. Bragdon, Henrik Malchau, Xunhua Yuan et al. · Journal of Orthopaedic Research® · 2002 · 145 citations