Is povidone iodine an alternative to silver nitrate for renal pelvic instillation sclerotherapy in chyluria?

Shailendra Goel, Anil Mandhani, Aneesh Srivastava, Rakesh Kapoor, Sanjay Gogoi, Anant Kumar, Mahendra Bhandari

British Journal of Urology · 2004 · 52 citations · 13 references

Concepts

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: To compare the efficacy and toxicity of 1% silver nitrate, 0.2% povidone iodine and 50% dextrose in renal pelvic instillation sclerotherapy (RPIS) for chyluria. PATIENTS AND METHODS: In a prospective randomized comparative study from January 1999 to June 2003, 106 patients (61 males and 45 females; mean age 36 years, sd 12, range 14-65) were randomized to receive 1% silver nitrate, 0.2% povidone iodine or 50% dextrose as RPIS. In all, nine doses were given at 8-h intervals, and patients followed at 6 weeks and then at 3-monthly intervals. Patients with 'persistence' or 'recurrence' of chyluria were treated with second course of RPIS using same sclerosant. RESULTS: The dextrose treatment was discontinued at mid-term because of poor success (one of 21 patients, P < 0.001). Of 85 patients, 44 received silver nitrate and 41 povidone iodine; both groups were well-matched and the mean follow-up was 28.4 and 23.3 months, respectively. 'Immediate clearance' was recorded in 91% and 98%, and recurrence in 21% and 22% of patients after the first course of RPIS, after silver nitrate and povidone, respectively; Kaplan-Meier estimates of 'disease-free duration' in the two groups (23.6 vs 20.1 months) were also similar (P = 0.7906). The cumulative success rate after two courses of RPIS was 82% (silver nitrate) and 83% (povidone; P = 1.0). Five (11%) patients in the silver nitrate and one (2%) in the povidone group had significant flank pain during treatment. CONCLUSIONS: Povidone iodine 0.2% is as effective for RPIS as 1% silver nitrate.

References

13