Jim Crow 2.0? Why States Consider and Adopt Restrictive Voter Access Policies

Keith Gunnar Bentele, Erin O’Brien

Perspectives on Politics · 2013 · 288 citations · 84 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Recent years have seen a dramatic rise in state laws that restrict voter access—such as ID and citizenship requirements, registration limits, absentee ballot restrictions, and reduced early voting—while political operatives often attribute malicious motives to opponents of such measures. The study aims to provide empirical clarity to the partisan debate by examining factors linked to the proposal and adoption of restrictive voter access legislation from 2006–2011. The authors employ multiple specialized regression techniques to analyze the determinants of both proposal and passage of restrictive voter laws. The analysis shows that proposals and passage of restrictive voter laws are highly partisan, strategic, and racialized, driven primarily by efforts to demobilize minority voters, especially African Americans, and that these policies are linked to broader social welfare and criminal justice reforms that further reduce electoral access for marginalized groups.

Abstract

Recent years have seen a dramatic increase in state legislation likely to reduce access for some voters, including photo identification and proof of citizenship requirements, registration restrictions, absentee ballot voting restrictions, and reductions in early voting. Political operatives often ascribe malicious motives when their opponents either endorse or oppose such legislation. In an effort to bring empirical clarity and epistemological standards to what has been a deeply-charged, partisan, and frequently anecdotal debate, we use multiple specialized regression approaches to examine factors associated with both the proposal and adoption of restrictive voter access legislation from 2006–2011. Our results indicate that proposal and passage are highly partisan, strategic, and racialized affairs. These findings are consistent with a scenario in which the targeted demobilization of minority voters and African Americans is a central driver of recent legislative developments. We discuss the implications of these results for current partisan and legal debates regarding voter restrictions and our understanding of the conditions incentivizing modern suppression efforts. Further, we situate these policies within developments in social welfare and criminal justice policy that collectively reduce electoral access among the socially marginalized.

References

84