Highly Reproducible Bactericidal Activity Test Results by Using a Modified National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards Broth Macrodilution Technique

Abstract

Bactericidal testing historically has exhibited variable reproducibility, even when prior standardized methods were employed. Several modifications to the National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards (NCCLS) broth macrodilution method are proposed to improve reproducibility. Recommended changes from the approved NCCLS guidelines (M21-A and M26-A) include omitting serum supplementation of Mueller-Hinton broth, incubating tubes at 35 degrees C for 24 h with no agitation until they are sampled, running all tests in duplicate with six dilutions instead of nine, reincubating the test for an additional 24 h to resolve discrepant bactericidal activity test results, using a single 0.1-ml sample from each clear tube for subculture, and adopting an alternate method for calculating endpoint determination. In order to test these recommendations in a clinical laboratory setting, we used the modified methodology on 224 separate tests for bactericidal activity. There were 102 serum bactericidal titer (SBT) and 122 minimum bactericidal concentration (MBC) assays performed. By defining reproducibility as agreement between duplicate tests +/- 1 dilution, we found 207 of 224 tests (92%) were reproducible at the 24-h subculture point (94% for the SBT assay and 91% for the MBC assay). When the 17 assays with discrepant results were incubated an additional 24 h for a second subculture, only 1 of 224 tests (0.4%) remained discrepant. The method used is practical for a clinical laboratory that chooses to perform bactericidal activity testing and assures a high level of reproducibility between duplicate assays. The total cost of a test was approximately $25.00.