The Neural Career of Sensory-motor Metaphors

Rutvik H. Desai, Jeffrey R. Binder, Lisa L. Conant, Quintino R. Mano, Mark S. Seidenberg

Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience · 2010 · 350 citations · 60 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The role of sensory‑motor systems in conceptual understanding is debated, with many abstract concepts thought to be grasped metaphorically via concrete sensory‑motor domains such as actions. The study proposes that the anterior inferior parietal lobule functions as an interface between sensory‑motor and conceptual systems, playing a key role in both. Using fMRI, the authors compared neural responses to literal action, metaphoric action, and abstract sentences across varying familiarity levels. Lit and metaphoric action sentences activated the left anterior inferior parietal lobule, with metaphoric sentences additionally engaging the right homologous area, whereas both metaphoric and abstract sentences activated left superior temporal regions; primary motor and biological motion areas showed inverse correlation with familiarity, suggesting that metaphor comprehension involves sensory‑motor simulations that become less detailed as familiarity increases and also relies on abstract lexical‑semantic codes.

Abstract

The role of sensory-motor systems in conceptual understanding has been controversial. It has been proposed that many abstract concepts are understood metaphorically through concrete sensory-motor domains such as actions. Using fMRI, we compared neural responses with literal action (Lit; The daughter grasped the flowers), metaphoric action (Met; The public grasped the idea), and abstract (Abs; The public understood the idea) sentences of varying familiarity. Both Lit and Met sentences activated the left anterior inferior parietal lobule, an area involved in action planning, with Met sentences also activating a homologous area in the right hemisphere, relative to Abs sentences. Both Met and Abs sentences activated the left superior temporal regions associated with abstract language. Importantly, activation in primary motor and biological motion perception regions was inversely correlated with Lit and Met familiarity. These results support the view that the understanding of metaphoric action retains a link to sensory-motor systems involved in action performance. However, the involvement of sensory-motor systems in metaphor understanding changes through a gradual abstraction process whereby relatively detailed simulations are used for understanding unfamiliar metaphors, and these simulations become less detailed and involve only secondary motor regions as familiarity increases. Consistent with these data, we propose that anterior inferior parietal lobule serves as an interface between sensory-motor and conceptual systems and plays an important role in both domains. The similarity of abstract and metaphoric sentences in the activation of left superior temporal regions suggests that action metaphor understanding is not completely based on sensory-motor simulations but relies also on abstract lexical-semantic codes.

References

60