An experimental comparison between different technologies arising for public lighting: LED luminaires replacing high pressure sodium lamps

Abstract

This work deals with the analysis and photometric comparison between different systems concepts for public lighting, hence the solid state lighting (SSL) employing LED luminaires with electronic drivers and the conventional high pressure sodium (HPS) lamp based luminaires along with electromagnetic ballasts. The study and comparison raise question on the relative perception of the human eye to different light sources with different spectral distributions, devoting special attention to low luminance conditions (scotopic) such as those present on public roadway lighting. Different LED-based luminaires are tested, in the lab and in loco. Photometric data of a SSL system being currently installed for the replacement of current HPS luminaires at the School of Engineering of the Federal University of Juiz de Fora are provided for the analysis and comparison.