Dentomaxillofacial Radiology · 2004 · 105 citations · 21 references
DentistryOral RadiologyRadiologyDental RadiologyDiagnostic ImagingRadiation ProtectionDental ImagingDental RadiographyDigital Dental ImagingIntraoral RadiographyDental Digital RadiographyDigital Intraoral RadiographyExposure-time RelationshipFilm-based Intraoral RadiographyPatient Dose ReductionPhosphor Plate ImagingRadiographic Exposure ParametersRadiographic Quality Assessment
The study aimed to determine how exposure time affects the diagnostic acceptability of digital radiographs versus film and to assess potential dose reductions for dental practice. Researchers captured series of intraoral radiographs on five dry bone specimens using five digital systems with progressively longer exposure times, then had seven observers evaluate each series to identify diagnostically acceptable and preferred images. Digital systems exhibited a narrow acceptable exposure range, with solid‑state devices requiring less radiation than film and alerting dentists to overexposure, whereas phosphor plate systems tolerated a wide range and produced high‑dose images that still appeared diagnostically acceptable, potentially leading to unnecessary radiation exposure.
To investigate the range of diagnostically acceptable digital radiographs and film as a function of exposure time, as well as the relationship to dose reduction and consequences for dental practice.Five systems for intraoral radiography were used to take a series of radiographs, with increasing exposure times, of five different dry bone specimens. Seven observers evaluated the 25 series of radiographs. The observers had to determine which radiographs of each series were acceptable for dental diagnostics and which radiograph of each series they preferred.For Ektaspeed Plus film, the exposure time for the preferred radiograph was 0.52 s, with a range of diagnostically acceptable radiographs from 0.23-1.02 s. The preferred radiograph of the solid-state systems required less radiation than film (Sirona, 0.13 s; MPDx 0.35 s). The exposure range of these systems is narrow. In contrast, the exposure range of the phosphor plate systems is very wide. The preferred radiograph of the phosphor plate systems required high exposure (Digora, 1.21 s; Gendex DenOptix, 1.16 s).All digital systems require less exposure than film for diagnostically acceptable radiographs, but this is less obvious for preferred radiographs. Solid-state systems alert the dentist when a too long exposure time is used by a lack of image quality; phosphor plate systems, however, produce good quality radiographs even at high exposure times, which may result in an unnecessarily high dose.
21