Does wireless sensor network scale? A measurement study on GreenOrbs

Yunhao Liu, Yuan He, Mo Li, Jiliang Wang, Kebin Liu, Lufeng Mo, Wei Dong, Zheng Yang, Min Xi, Jizhong Zhao,

2011 · 156 citations · 42 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Despite extensive efforts to build sensor systems, the scalability of wireless sensor networks remains unclear at the system level, prompting investigation from a real‑world deployment perspective. The study asks whether wireless sensor networks truly scale and proposes three conjectures to guide future large‑scale designs. The authors instrumented the GreenOrbs network across the protocol stack to observe layer‑level behavior. Findings reveal that a few nodes bottleneck the network, concurrency drives dynamics more than environmental changes, and an event‑based routing structure can be trained to adapt better to unpredictable environmental impacts.

Abstract

In spite of the remarkable efforts the community put to build the sensor systems, an essential question still remains unclear at the system level, motivating us to explore the answer from a point of real-world deployment view. Does the wireless sensor network really scale? We present findings from a large scale operating sensor network system, GreenOrbs, with up to 330 nodes deployed in the forest. We instrument such an operating network throughout the protocol stack and present observations across layers in the network. Based on our findings from the system measurement, we propose and make initial efforts to validate three conjectures that give potential guidelines for future designs of large scale sensor networks. (1) A small portion of nodes bottlenecks the entire network, and most of the existing network indicators may not accurately capture them. (2) The network dynamics mainly come from the inherent concurrency of network operations instead of environment changes. (3) The environment, although the dynamics are not as significant as we assumed, has an unpredictable impact on the sensor network. We suggest that an event-based routing structure can be trained optimal and thus better adapt to the wild environment when building a large scale sensor network.

References

42