WYSIWIS revised: early experiences with multiuser interfaces

Mark Stefik, Daniel G. Bobrow, Gregg Foster, Stan Lanning, Deborah Tatar

ACM Transactions on Information Systems · 1987 · 547 citations · 9 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

WYSIWIS is a foundational abstraction for multiuser interfaces that mirrors a chalkboard, allowing all participants to see the same written content and each other's pointers. The paper investigates design choices for first‑generation meeting tools based on WYSIWIS, aiming to accommodate shifting information‑sharing needs during process transitions. The authors present several multiuser interface examples and relax WYSIWIS constraints along display space, display time, subgroup population, and view congruence to reduce conflicts. They find that while WYSIWIS is essential, strict enforcement is too inflexible, leading to conflicts between group and individual needs over shared display space and time.

Abstract

WYSIWIS (What You See Is What I See) is a foundational abstraction for multiuser interfaces that expresses many of the characteristics of a chalkboard in face-to-face meetings. In its strictest interpretation, it means that everyone can also see the same written information and also see where anyone else is pointing. In our attempts to build software support for collaboration in meetings, we have discovered that WYSIWIS is crucial, yet too inflexible when strictly enforced. This paper is about the design issues and choices that arose in our first generation of meeting tools based on WYSIWIS. Several examples of multiuser interfaces that start from this abstraction are presented. These tools illustrate that there are inherent conflicts between the needs of a group and the needs of individuals, since user interfaces compete for the same display space and meeting time. To help minimize the effect of these conflicts, constraints were relaxed along four key dimensions of WYSIWIS: display space, time of display, subgroup population, and congruence of view. Meeting tools must be designed to support the changing needs of information sharing during process transitions, as subgroups are formed and dissolved, as individuals shift their focus of activity, and as the group shifts from multiple parallel activities to a single focused activity and back again.

References

9