Harvard Educational Review · 1973 · 225 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesPublic PolicySocial PolicyChild PolicyChild WelfarePolicy AnalysisAbuse PreventionChild AbuseChild MaltreatmentChild Maltreatment PreventionChild NeglectChild ProtectionCase Investigation ReportsChild Abuse Reporting SystemsChild Maltreatment InterventionChild Maltreatment SurveillanceChild Neglect PreventionPrevention Of Child VictimizationReporting Of Child VictimizationSocial Policy Design
Media coverage has spotlighted the challenges faced by severely abused and neglected children in America, yet hard data on which social policies are most effective remain scarce. The study aims to estimate abuse incidence and analyze three social policies—national health screening, child‑rearing education, and abusive‑family profiling—to identify effective interventions. The authors review multiple data sources and evaluate each of the three policy options under two underlying themes. They find that incomplete, non‑experimental data can still assess policy effectiveness and recommend systematic studies to enable firm comparisons of program impact.
Both the print and electronic media recently have highlighted the problems faced by severely abased and neglected children in America. Many suggestions have been offered for ameliorating the conditions leading to child abuse and neglect,but few hard data exist to tell us which social policies can be most effective in combatting these conditions. In this article, several sources of data are examined to estimate the incidence of abuse, its social and demographic features, and the nature of available child abuse case reports. Three potential social policies are analyzed in detail: national health screening, education in child rearing, and the development of profiles of abusing families with the hope of offering them preventive help. Each analysis has two underlying themes. First, even with incomplete data it is often possible to evaluate the probable effectiveness of a social policy before it is implemented. Second, data initially collected in a non-experimental setting ran still be used to suggest improvements in policy. The author concludes with a series of recommendations urging more systematic and carefully designed investigations of reporting systems and ameliorative efforts. Such investigations are necessary to enable firm inferences about the comparative effectiveness of different programs to reduce the incidence of child abuse and neglect.