What Unites Right-Wing Populists in Western Europe?

Elisabeth Ivarsflaten

Comparative Political Studies · 2007 · 815 citations · 35 references

Concepts

TL;DR

There is no scholarly consensus on the grievances mobilized by Western European right‑wing populists, and existing literature proposes three competing models focusing on economic change, political elitism and corruption, and immigration. The study aims to evaluate these three grievance mobilization models using cross‑sectional survey data from seven Western European countries. Multinomial probit analysis is applied to the survey data to test the models. The analysis shows that only immigration grievances consistently unite successful right‑wing populist parties, while economic or political grievances are not required for electoral success.

Abstract

Unlike for the green party family, no empirically backed scholarly consensus exists about the grievances mobilized by populist right parties in Western Europe. To the contrary, three competing grievance mobilization models can be distinguished in the existing literature. These models focus on grievances arising from economic changes, political elitism and corruption, and immigration. This study discusses these three grievance mobilization models and tests them on comparable cross-sectional survey data for all seven relevant countries using multinomial probit analysis. The study finds that no populist right party performed well in elections around 2002 without mobilizing grievances over immigration. However, it finds several examples of populist right parties experiencing electoral success without mobilizing grievances over economic changes or political elitism and corruption. This study therefore solves a long-standing disagreement in the literature by comprehensively showing that only the appeal on the immigration issue unites all successful populist right parties.

References

35