Anti‐Manic and Prophylactic Effects of Carbamazepine (Tegretol) on Manic Depressive Psychosis A Preliminary Report

Teruo Ōkuma, Akira Kishimoto, Masaiwa Inoue, Hisashi Matsumoto, Atsushi Ogura, Toji Matsushita, Takehisa Nakao, Chikara Ogura

Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences · 1973 · 147 citations · 5 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study discusses the mechanism by which carbamazepine may be effective in endogenous manic‑depressive psychosis. The study investigates carbamazepine’s anti‑manic, anti‑depressive, and prophylactic effects in 50 patients with endogenous manic‑depressive psychosis. Patients received carbamazepine at 200–1,200 mg daily, typically 400–600 mg. In 50 patients, carbamazepine was markedly effective in 23 % of manic episodes, effective in 19 %, slightly effective in 16 %, and ineffective in 42 %; depressive episodes were markedly effective in 2 % and ineffective in 48 %; prophylactic use was markedly effective in 48 % of manic and 45 % of depressive episodes, with no significant influence from drug combinations, age of onset, or illness course, and side‑effects led to discontinuation in 8 % of cases.

Abstract

SUMMARY The anti‐manic, anti‐depressive and prophylactic effects of carbamazepine (CAZP, Tegretol‐Ciba Geigy) on the endogenous mani‐depressive psychosis (MDP) were investigated on 50 MDP cases. The dosage of the drug ranged from 200 to 1,200 mg daily (usually 400 to 600 mg). The effect of CAZP on 33 manic states was: “markedly effective” seven (23%), “effective” six (19%), “slightly effective” five (16%), “ineffective” 13 (42%), whereas the effect on six depressive states was: “markedly effective” one and “ineffective” five. No definite relationship was found between the kinds of drugs in combination use and the effect of CAZP. No significant difference of the CAZP effect was found in the four patient groups with different age of onset of the illness, nor among the “continuous,”“frequent” and “periodic” type cases. The prophylactic effect of CAZP on 27 cases in which the assessment of the effect on the manic episode was possible was: “markedly effective” 13 (48%), “effective” seven (26%) and “ineffective” seven (26%), whereas that for depressive episode was: 12 (45%), two (7%) and 13 (48%), and the result of the general assessment on each patient was 14 (43%), 10 (30%) and nine (27%), respectively. The kinds of drugs in combination use, age of onset and type of course of the illness did not have any influence on the prophylactic effect of CAZP. The prophylactic effect on MDP of CAZP did not parallel that of lithium salt, but CAZP may be effective on cases which did not respond to lithium and vice versa . Side‐effects such as ataxia, dizziness, exanthema, drowsiness and headache were observed in five of the cases, and the CAZP was discontinued in four of them. The mechanism of effectiveness of the CAZP on MDP was discussed.

References

5