Understanding the Use of Ecosystem Service Knowledge in Decision Making: Lessons from International Experiences of Spatial Planning

Emily McKenzie, Stephen Posner, Patrícia Tillmann, Joanna R. Bernhardt, Kirsten Howard, Amy Rosenthal

Environment and Planning C Government and Policy · 2014 · 224 citations · 59 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Limited understanding of how ecosystem service knowledge is used in decision making hampers learning from and replicating success stories. The study investigates the use of ecosystem service knowledge in spatial planning across three international cases—Belize, Vancouver Island, and Oahu. In each case, decision makers, scientists, and stakeholders collaborated using a standardized ecosystem service accounting tool, and the authors evaluated interview, survey, and observation data to assess conceptual, strategic, and instrumental use. The analysis revealed that conceptual use dominates early planning, while strategic and instrumental uses emerge iteratively later, with conceptual and strategic use building understanding and compromise that enable instrumental application, and attributes such as meaningful participation, scenario development, and integration of local and traditional knowledge support these uses.

Abstract

The limited understanding of how ecosystem service knowledge (ESK) is used in decision making constrains our ability to learn from, replicate, and convey success stories. We explore use of ESK in decision making in three international cases: national coastal planning in Belize; regional marine spatial planning on Vancouver Island, Canada; and regional land-use planning on the island of Oahu, Hawaii. Decision makers, scientists, and stakeholders collaborated in each case to use a standardized ecosystem service accounting tool to inform spatial planning. We evaluate interview, survey, and observation data to assess evidence of ‘conceptual’, ‘strategic’, and ‘instrumental’ use of ESK. We find evidence of all modes: conceptual use dominates early planning, while strategic and instrumental uses occur iteratively in middle and late stages. Conceptual and strategic uses of ESK build understanding and compromise that facilitate instrumental use. We highlight attributes of ESK, characteristics of the process, and general conditions that appear to affect how knowledge is used. Meaningful participation, scenario development, and integration of local and traditional knowledge emerge as important for particular uses.

References

59