2008 · 179 citations · 3 references
ComputingComputer EngineeringComputer ScienceComputer NetworksEmbedded SystemsReal-time SystemsCommunication NetworksIndustrial Communication NetworksNetwork ArchitectureNetwork Performance AnalysisNetwork ProtocolsReal-time Communication ProtocolsBasic MistakesEthernetIndustrial EthernetReal-time EthernetReal-time Industrial CommunicationReal-time Networking
Ethernet is becoming the preferred industrial communication platform, supporting many protocols tailored to industrial needs. This study provides a rigorous analysis of the Real‑time Ethernet protocols PROFINET IRT and EtherCAT, correcting common misconceptions in prior work. The authors compare the real‑time performance of PROFINET IRT and EtherCAT by evaluating performance‑affecting factors in realistic scenarios. The analysis shows that EtherCAT outperforms PROFINET IRT, and explains the reasons for this advantage.
Ethernet is emerging as the preferred industrial communication platform upon which a multitude of protocols and solutions specially targeted at industrial communication requirements have been developed. This paper concentrates on a set of protocols popularly referred to as the Real-time Ethernet protocols and analyses two key technologies, namely PROFINET IRT and EtherCAT. The real-time performance characteristics of PROFINET IRT and EtherCAT is compared by looking into what factors affect their performance in a set of realistic scenarios. The goal is to provide a scientifically solid study on this subject where many presentations are seriously flawed by basic mistakes, misunderstandings or biased views. The detailed analysis presented here shows that EtherCAT has a performance advantage over PROFINET IRT and the reasons for this are discussed.
3