Design of reactive distillations for acetic acid esterification

Yeong‐Tarng Tang, Yiwei Chen, Hsiao‐Ping Huang, Cheng‐Ching Yu, Shih‐Bo Hung, Ming‐Jer Lee

AIChE Journal · 2005 · 194 citations · 25 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Reactive distillation offers an attractive alternative for reversible reactions such as etherification and esterification, but the discrete nature of species and complex phase equilibria obscure its understanding. The authors studied acetic acid esterification with five alcohols (C1–C5), linked macroscopic flowsheet types I–III to microscopic phase equilibria, and devised a systematic, cost‑optimizing design procedure that identifies dominant variables, analyzes operational characteristics, and explores economic potentials. Their results demonstrate that reactive distillation design can be systematized by generating flowsheets from phase equilibria and completing them with a sequential design, yielding several novel flowsheets not reported elsewhere. © 2005 American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE J, 2005.

Abstract

Abstract The reactive distillation provides an attractive alternative for reaction/separation processes with reversible reactions, especially for etherification and esterification. The discrete nature of chemical species and the complexity of phase equilibria seem to cloud the picture in understanding reactive distillation. The esterifications of acetic acid with five different alcohols, ranging from C 1 to C 5, are studied. First, qualitative relationships between macroscopic process flowsheet and microscopic phase equilibria are established, and the process flowsheets are classified into type I, II, and III for these five systems. Next, a systematic design procedure is devised to optimize the design, based on the total annual cost (TAC) and dominant design variables are identified for different flowsheets. Once quantitative design is available, process characteristic are analyzed and potential problems in process operation are identified. Finally, the economic potentials of these three different flowsheets are explored and explanations are given. The results clearly indicate that it is possible to systemize the design of reactive distillation by qualitatively generating flowsheet from phase equilibria and by quantitatively completing the process flow diagram from a sequential design procedure. Moreover, some of the flowsheets presented in this work cannot be found elsewhere in the open literature. © 2005 American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE J, 2005

References

25