BusinessPsychologyDecision TheoryPersuasionPragmaticsBounded RationalityDecision Under AmbiguityAlternative PossibilitiesPrinciple Of Alternate Possibilities
An object's disposition to A in circumstances C is masked if circumstances C obtain without the object Aing. This paper explores an analogous sense in which abilities can be masked, and it uses the results of this exploration to motivate an analysis of agents’ abilities in terms of dispositions. This analysis is then shown to provide the resources to defend a version of the Principle of Alternate Possibilities against Frankfurt-style counterexamples. Although this principle is often taken to be congenial to incompatibilism concerning free action and determinism, the paper concludes by using the dispositional analysis of abilities to argue for compatibilism, and to show why the ‘master argument’ for incompatibilism is unsound.
6
Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person
Harry G. Frankfurt · The Journal of Philosophy · 1971 · 4.4K citations
Alternate Possibilities and Moral Responsibility
Harry G. Frankfurt · The Journal of Philosophy · 1969 · 2.4K citations
C. B. Martin · The Philosophical Quarterly · 1994 · 770 citations
Kadri Vihvelin · Philosophical Topics · 2004 · 188 citations
G.J. Warnock · Journal of Symbolic Logic · 1958 · 174 citations