Long term predictive values of cytology and human papillomavirus testing in cervical cancer screening: joint European cohort study

TLDR

To obtain large‑scale, generalisable data on the long‑term predictive value of cytology and HPV testing for cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade 3 or cancer (CIN3+). A multinational cohort study pooled data from seven primary HPV screening studies across six European countries, enrolling 24 295 women who had at least one cervical cytology or histopathology examination during follow‑up, to assess the long‑term cumulative incidence of CIN3+. The study found that HPV‑negative women had a six‑year CIN3+ incidence of 0.27% versus 0.97% for cytology‑negative women, with a 0.51% incidence at the common three‑year interval, and that HPV‑positive cytology‑negative women’s risk rose to 10% at six years while HPV‑negative cytology‑positive women remained below 3%, supporting six‑year HPV screening as safe and effective.

Abstract

<b>Objective</b> To obtain large scale and generalisable data on the long term predictive value of cytology and human papillomavirus (HPV) testing for development of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade 3 or cancer (CIN3+). <b>Design</b> Multinational cohort study with joint database analysis. <b>Setting</b> Seven primary HPV screening studies in six European countries. <b>Participants</b> 24 295 women attending cervical screening enrolled into HPV screening trials who had at least one cervical cytology or histopathology examination during follow-up. <b>Main outcome measure</b> Long term cumulative incidence of CIN3+. <b>Results</b> The cumulative incidence rate of CIN3+ after six years was considerably lower among women negative for HPV at baseline (0.27%, 95% confidence interval 0.12% to 0.45%) than among women with negative results on cytology (0.97%, 0.53% to 1.34%)). By comparison, the cumulative incidence rate for women with negative cytology results at the most commonly recommended screening interval in Europe (three years) was 0.51% (0.23% to 0.77%). The cumulative incidence rate among women with negative cytology results who were positive for HPV increased continuously over time, reaching 10% at six years, whereas the rate among women with positive cytology results who were negative for HPV remained below 3%. <b>Conclusions</b> A consistently low six year cumulative incidence rate of CIN3+ among women negative for HPV suggests that cervical screening strategies in which women are screened for HPV every six years are safe and effective.