PEDIATRICS · 2007 · 280 citations · 38 references
Health ProfessionsEmergency MedicinePediatricsPediatric Emergency CarePediatric Emergency MedicineResuscitationBasic Life SupportCardiopulmonary ResuscitationMedical EmergenciesPediatric EmergenciesPediatric ResuscitationRespiratory EmergenciesCardiopulmonary ArrestIn-hospital Pediatric Cardiac ArrestIn-hospital Pediatric ResuscitationOut-of-hospital Pediatric ResuscitationPediatric Cardiopulmonary ResuscitationPediatric Simulation TrainingResuscitation SimulationSimulation-based Resuscitation Training
In-hospital pediatric cardiopulmonary arrest outcomes are dismal, and while adult resuscitation quality is known to be low, pediatric data are scarce. The study aimed to measure median elapsed time to initiate key resuscitation maneuvers in simulated pediatric emergencies and to identify the types and frequency of errors during mock codes. A prospective observational study of 34 unannounced mock codes using mannequins or computerized simulators assessed time to key resuscitation maneuvers and deviations from American Heart Association guidelines. The study found significant delays—median times of 1.3 to 6.0 minutes for airway, breathing, circulation, physician arrival, and first team member—and that 75% of mock codes deviated from AHA pediatric basic life support protocols with 100% communication errors, underscoring the need for interventions targeting the first five minutes of resuscitation.
Outcomes of in-hospital pediatric cardiopulmonary arrest are dismal. Recent data suggest that the quality of basic and advanced life support delivered to adults is low and contributes to poor outcomes, but few data regarding pediatric events have been reported. The objectives of this study were to (1) measure the median elapsed time to initiate important resuscitation maneuvers in simulated pediatric medical emergencies (ie, "mock codes") and (2) identify the types and frequency of errors committed during pediatric mock codes.A prospective, observational study was conducted of 34 consecutive hospital-based mock codes. A mannequin or computerized simulator was used to enact unannounced, simulated crisis situations involving children with respiratory distress or insufficiency, respiratory arrest, hemodynamic instability, and/or cardiopulmonary arrest. Assessment included time elapsed to initiation of specific resuscitation maneuvers and deviation from American Heart Association guidelines.Among the 34 mock codes, the median time to assessment of airway and breathing was 1.3 minutes, to administration of oxygen was 2.0 minutes, to assessment of circulation was 4.0 minutes, to arrival of any physician was 3.0 minutes, and to arrival of first member of code team was 6.0 minutes. Among cardiopulmonary arrest scenarios, elapsed time to initiation of compressions was 1.5 minutes and to request for defibrillator was 4.3 minutes. In 75% of mock codes, the team deviated from American Heart Association pediatric basic life support protocols, and in 100% of mock codes there was a communication error.Alarming delays and deviations occur in the major components of pediatric resuscitation. Future educational and organizational interventions should focus on improving the quality of care delivered during the first 5 minutes of resuscitation. Simulation of pediatric crises can identify targets for educational intervention to improve pediatric cardiopulmonary resuscitation and, ideally, outcomes.
38
Quality of Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation During Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest
Richard O. Cummins, Douglas Chamberlain, Mary Fran Hazinski et al. · Circulation · 1997 · 583 citations
Health Professions, Emergency Medical Services, Emergency Medicine +16