Near-optimal intraprocedural branch alignment

Abstract

Branch alignment reorders the basic blocks of a program to minimize pipeline penalties due to control-transfer instructions. Prior work in branch alignment has produced useful heuristic methods. We present a branch alignment algorithm that usually achieves the minimum possible pipeline penalty and on our benchmarks averages within 0.3% of a provable optimum. We compare the control penalties and running times of our algorithm to an older, greedy approach and observe that both the greedy method and our method are close to the lower bound on control penalties, suggesting that greedy is good enough. Surprisingly, in actual execution our method produces programs that run noticeably faster than the greedy method. We also report results from training and testing on different data sets, validating that our results can be achieved in real-world usage. Training and testing on different data sets slightly reduced the benefits from both branch alignment algorithms, but the ranking of the algorithms does not change, and the bulk of the benefits remain.