Padding the Revolving Door: An Initial Assessment of the Uniform Alcoholism and Intoxication Treatment Act in Practice

Ronald W. Fagan, Armand L. Mauss

Social Problems · 1978 · 36 citations · 33 references

Concepts

Abstract

The widespread adoption of the Uniform Alcoholism and Intoxication Treatment Act raises important questions of theory and of policy. Because the Act is partly a move toward official medicalization and decriminalization of public drunkenness, it raises a theoretical question about the applicability of the “sick role” to public inebriates. It also raises policy questions about the differential efficacy of a medical vs. a criminal approach to the social control of public drunkenness. We draw upon both police records and public detoxification treatment records in a before-and-after study of the impact of the adoption of the new Act in the Seattle area. We find that many of the intentions of the Act seem to have been realized: (1) basically the same “clientele” that used to be processed through “the drunk tank” is now being processed through the public detoxification center, and (2) this clientele continues to be predominantly of the “skidroad” type; (3) the clientele is being handled primarily by civilian patrols, rather than by the police, although (4) the overall level of social control activity on skidroad, from both sources, remains about the same, a finding consistent with the Durkheim-Erikson “constancy dictum.” However, the most important expectation of the new Act, a decline in the classical “revolving door” pattern, is not being realized. In fact, the transition from drunktank to detox-center processing has been accompanied by a four-fold increase in recidivism, and only a small proportion of detox clients are accepting referral to treatment programs. Both theoretical and policy implications of these findings are discussed

References

33